Skip to content
BT BT

Pets News

  • Pets News
  • Pets Clinic
  • Pets Food
  • Animals
  • Pets Market
BT
BT

Pets News

BC woman ordered to give dog back to ex after ‘sharing ownership’ fell apart

Gino, 07/04/202326/03/2024

A recent BC Civil Resolution Tribunal decision offers a cautionary warning to couples who share pets during a relationship – even after they break up.

In the ruling, a woman was ordered to return a dog to her ex after a complicated arrangement went sour.

The dispute centered around a dog named Bentley, who was shared by a BC couple who were in a romantic relationship.

That relationship ended, but the two people continued to share a Bentley for eight years after the breakup. (Black Press Media isn’t identifying the two humans as the story is more about the lessons that can be learned from it.)

“The parties say they both paid for Bentley’s initial acquisition cost, and after they broke up, they shared custody of Bentley with each party taking the dog for three weeks at a time before handing him over to the other,” reads the CRT ruling.

This includes both people sharing expenses in regards to Bentley.

That arrangement seemed to work for eight years until the woman cut off access to the man, saying she “no longer felt comfortable” with him having access to Bentley.

The exact reason isn’t given, but the woman texts the man to say she has “discovered some pretty upsetting things” about the man, according to the ruling.

In July 2022, the man went to pick up the Bentley as per the schedule – along with the police to supervise – but he refused to give up the dog. The man hadn’t seen the dog for about 10 months when the case was heard by the CRT.

The man was asking to get access to Bentley or be compensated with $5,000.

“At law, pets are considered personal property,” reads the ruling. “This can become complicated when personal relationships break down because people don’t want their pets to be treated like other personal property that can be divided or sold to share the proceeds… I admit it can be difficult to determine who has a greater claim to a pet’s ownership and possession.”

Some issues to be considered, according to the ruling, include who bought the pet, did one person own the pet at the start of the relationship and who took the most care of the dog – including exercise. This was complicated because they shared most everything equally with Bentley and the CRT said in its ruling that “clearly, a dog cannot be divided.”

The man argued in the hearing that “Bentley has always had a strong connection with him.” The woman also didn’t detail specific reasons why she was no longer comfortable with the man having access to Bentley, so the adjudicator dismissed that.

The ruling said that the woman unilaterally cutting off access “displays a lack of ability to put Bentley’s best interests above her own personal interests.”

And so, the woman was ordered to return the Bentley within 21 days of the decision, plus reimburse the ex for the tribunal fees.

Do you have a story tip? Email: [email protected].

Follow us on Twitter and Instagram, and like us on Facebook.

CourtDogs

Animals

Post navigation

Previous post
Next post

Related Posts

Automotive Manufacturing Business Indonesia Car Sales

18/09/202326/03/2024

Meanwhile, per capita GDP was weakening due to slowing economic progress. Lastly, the weak rupiah (which had been weakening since mid-2013 amid the US taper tantrum) made imports dearer. Given that many car parts still must be imported therefore elevating manufacturing costs for Indonesian automotive producers, worth tags on automobiles…

Read More

Charli D’Amelio Reveals Landon Barker Got Tattoo of Her Eye After Losing Game of Rock, Paper, Scissors (Exclusive)

30/06/202326/03/2024

The social media megastar, who recently partnered with Tamagotchi Uni as a global ambassador, spoke to PEOPLE about Barker, her fave mini-games and more Matt Winkelmeyer/Getty Charli D’Amelio has her eye on Landon Barker — literally. At the beginning of June, Barker, the 19-year-old son of drummer Travis Barker, showed…

Read More

Adoptable pets in Mass.: 12-year-old beagle needs an easy-going home

18/04/202326/03/2024

A 12-year-old beagle with arthritis needs a forever home that’s easy-going, the Dakin Humane Society says. “Meet Brian, an easy-going older Beagle who is looking for an easy-going home,” the humane society said. “He enjoys the comforts of indoors but really enjoys being outside exploring like Beagles do.” The humane…

Read More

Recent Posts

  • The Impact of Social Media on Sports Marketing
  • The Importance of Real Estate Compliance
  • The Art Behind Album Covers: Visual Identity in Music
  • The Language of Symbols in Art
  • Exploring Contemporary Native American Art

Tags

analysis arabia Art automotive beauty berita business camera cooking developments devices digital estate excessive fashion gadget headlines health house housing improvement indonesia information jewellery jewelry latest malaysia market mobility motoring movies newest occasions online pictures property saudi shopping sport sports suggestions tales technology updates world

About Us

  • Contact Us
  • Disclosure Policy
  • Sitemap

Partnerlik

©2025 BT | WordPress Theme by SuperbThemes

WhatsApp us